AI regulation rather than ban is better option: CJI
Chief Justice Surya Kant argued that regulating generative AI is more effective than banning it, noting the technology has disrupted traditional academic integrity. He highlighted how AI challenges the assumption that exam answers reflect a student's own knowledge.

Chief Justice of India Surya Kant has stated that a regulatory framework is a superior approach to handling generative artificial intelligence compared to an outright ban. Speaking on the evolving legal and ethical challenges posed by the technology, the Chief Justice emphasized the need for balanced oversight. He noted that while the technology offers significant benefits, its unchecked use creates complex problems for institutions and society. The judiciary is currently observing how these tools are being deployed in various sectors to ensure they do not undermine established norms.
A central concern raised by Justice Kant is the impact of generative AI on education and assessment. He pointed out that the technology has unsettled the long-held assumption that an answer sheet submitted by a student reflects their personal knowledge and understanding. When AI tools can generate coherent and accurate responses, it becomes difficult for educators to verify the authenticity of the work. This shift forces academic institutions to rethink their evaluation methods and integrity policies to maintain the credibility of their degrees and certifications.
The Chief Justice's remarks come at a time when governments and regulatory bodies worldwide are grappling with how to manage the rapid advancement of AI. In India, where the education system is vast and diverse, the implications of AI use in exams are particularly significant. A ban might stifle innovation, but a lack of regulation could lead to widespread academic dishonesty. The judiciary's stance suggests a preference for nuanced rules that allow for the responsible use of technology while protecting the integrity of educational outcomes and other critical sectors.
Comments 0