Second DNA Test Can't Be Ordered Merely Because It Causes No Prejudice To Opposite Party: Kerala High Court
The Kerala High Court ruled that a second DNA test cannot be ordered simply because it does not prejudice the opposite party. The judgment warned against a legal approach that could inadvertently support claims of illegitimacy.

In a recent hearing, the court examined a petition that sought a repeat DNA test to resolve a dispute over parentage. The petitioner argued that the first test was inconclusive, while the respondent contended that a second test would be unnecessary and could cause emotional distress. The bench emphasized that the judiciary must balance scientific evidence with the potential social consequences of labeling a child as illegitimate.
The judges cited legal principles that protect individuals from unnecessary intrusion into private matters, especially when the outcome does not affect the legal rights of the parties involved. They noted that ordering a second test solely on the basis that it would not harm the opposite side could set a precedent where courts routinely intervene in family matters without clear justification. The ruling therefore restricts the use of DNA testing to cases where it directly influences legal outcomes such as custody, inheritance, or criminal liability.
Legal scholars see the decision as a reinforcement of privacy rights within family law. It underscores the need for courts to rely on solid evidentiary grounds before ordering scientific procedures that may have lasting social implications. The judgment also serves as a reminder to lawyers to present compelling reasons when seeking additional forensic testing, ensuring that the legal process remains focused on substantive justice rather than procedural excess.
Comments 0