Election Commission’s Credibility Tested as Calls for New Safeguards Grow
Former chief election commissioner S.Y. Quraishi warned that the Election Commission of India has faced mounting pressure since 2019, with the 2024 Lok Sabha turnout controversy eroding public confidence. His appeal for statutory safeguards has ignited a debate among lawmakers, jurists and civil‑society groups about the future independence of the body.

In a recent interview, S.Y. Quraishi highlighted a series of incidents that have strained the Election Commission's reputation, beginning with disputed turnout figures in the 2024 Lok Sabha election. He noted that the commission's decisions on voter verification and counting procedures were repeatedly challenged in courts, creating a perception of partisan bias. The erosion of trust, he argued, threatens the very foundation of India's democratic process, as citizens begin to question the legitimacy of electoral outcomes.
The call for reinforced safeguards has sparked a vigorous discussion within the political establishment and the judiciary. Lawmakers from several parties have proposed amendments to the Representation of the People Act, seeking to insulate the commission from executive interference and to establish an independent oversight panel. Meanwhile, senior judges have signaled willingness to scrutinise the commission's procedural lapses more closely, suggesting that judicial review could become a regular feature of electoral disputes. Civil‑society organisations have also mobilised, organising seminars and publishing policy briefs that call for transparent appointment processes and clearer accountability mechanisms.
If the proposed reforms gain traction, the next general election could be conducted under a markedly different institutional framework. Strengthened safeguards may restore voter confidence, encourage higher turnout, and reduce the frequency of post‑election litigations that currently burden the courts. Conversely, failure to act could deepen cynicism, embolden political actors to manipulate electoral machinery, and invite international criticism of India's democratic standards. The outcome will shape the balance of power between the electorate, the commission and the political class for years to come.
Comments 0